Tottenham’s Best and Worst: Rating Each Premier League Period Supervisor

From the tactical revolution of Mauricio Pochettino to the hapless tenure of Ossie Ardiles, Tottenham Hotspur’s managerial historical past within the Premier League period tells a narrative of hovering ambition and crushing disappointment. Utilizing complete statistical knowledge masking each everlasting and caretaker appointment since 1992, this text ranks the most effective and worst to have sat within the White Hart Lane and the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium dugout.

Few golf equipment have skilled such wild extremes of managerial fortune as Spurs. The north London membership has oscillated between intervals of real title rivalry and years of mid-table mediocrity, and the figures make for fascinating studying. Factors-percentage, the proportion of accessible league factors truly received is probably the most dependable single metric for evaluating managers throughout completely different eras, because it accounts pretty for the variety of video games managed.

Former Tottenham Hotspur midfielder, Jamie O’Hara, and lots of different soccer pundits are calling for the rapid substitute of present Tottenham Hotspur interim supervisor. They declare that Tudor lacks the power required to galvanise the struggling Spurs workforce right into a successful workforce that’s able to avoiding relegation to the Championship.

Tottenham Hotspur Supervisor’s Premier League Information 1992-93 to 2025-26

Supervisor	Interval	P	W	D	L	F	A	GD	Win%	Factors	Max Pts	% Pts
Tim Sherwood	2013-2014	22	13	3	6	40	30	10	59.09	42	66	63.64
Mauricio Pochettino	2014-2019	202	113	43	46	373	207	166	55.94	382	606	63.04
Antonio Conte	2021-2023	56	32	9	15	112	64	48	57.14	105	168	62.50
André Villas-Boas	2012-2013	54	29	12	13	81	67	14	53.70	99	162	61.11
Harry Redknapp	2008-2012	144	71	37	36	228	141	87	49.00	250	432	57.87
José Mourinho	2019-2021	58	27	14	17	97	67	30	46.55	95	174	54.60
Ryan Mason	2021 & 2023	12	6	1	5	25	19	6	50.00	19	36	52.77
Martin Jol	2004-2007	114	47	30	37	169	148	21	41.23	171	342	50.00
Nuno Espírito Santo	2021	10	5	0	5	9	16	-7	50.00	15	30	50.00
Ange Postecoglou	2023-2025	76	31	11	34	138	126	12	40.79	104	228	45.61
Livermore / Clemence	1992-1993	42	16	11	15	60	66	-6	38.10	59	126	46.83
Gerry Francis	1994-1997	119	43	36	40	150	142	8	36.13	165	357	46.22
Christian Gross	1997-1998	26	9	7	10	35	40	-5	34.62	34	78	43.59
George Graham	1998-2001	97	32	29	36	128	123	5	32.99	125	291	42.96
Glenn Hoddle	2001-2003	89	32	18	39	116	141	-25	35.96	114	267	42.70
David Pleat	2003-2004	33	12	6	15	42	45	-3	36.36	42	99	42.42
Caretaker Managers	1992-2014	8	3	1	4	10	33	-23	37.50	10	24	41.67
Jacques Santini	2004	11	3	4	4	6	8	-2	27.27	13	33	39.39
Juande Ramos	2007-2008	35	10	11	14	53	50	3	28.57	41	105	39.05
Ossie Ardiles	1993-1994	54	16	14	24	75	83	-8	29.63	62	162	38.27
Thomas Frank	2025-2026	26	7	8	11	36	37	-1	26.92	29	78	37.18
Christian Stellini	2023	4	1	1	2	6	11	-5	25.00	4	12	33.33
Igor Tudor	2026	1	0	0	1	1	4	-3	0.00	0	3	0.00
Totals	1992-2026	1,293	558	306	429	1,990	1,668	322	43.16	1,980	3,879	51.04

The Rating: Factors Proportion within the Premier League

Throughout 23 distinct managerial spells within the Premier League, Spurs have averaged a factors proportion of roughly 51%, that means the membership has traditionally secured simply over half of accessible factors. The hole between the most effective and worst, nonetheless, is dramatic, a chasm of over 60 proportion factors separating the elite from the failures.

The info tells a transparent story on the prime finish. Tim Sherwood’s short-lived tenure produced a startling 63.64% factors return, albeit throughout simply 22 video games. Mauricio Pochettino’s 5 seasons sit just under at 63.04% from 202 video games, making his probably the most statistically spectacular sustained interval within the Premier League period. Antonio Conte (62.50%) and André Villas-Boas (61.11%) additionally rank among the many elite, although every had their tenures ended abruptly and controversially.

The Greatest: A Golden Age Beneath Pochettino

No supervisor defines Tottenham’s Premier League identification fairly like Mauricio Pochettino. Between 2014 and 2019, the Argentine remodeled Spurs from perennial top-half underachievers into real Champions League regulars, famously threatening the title race in 2015–16 and finally guiding the membership to a Champions League last in 2019. His factors proportion of 63.04% from 202 Premier League video games is the benchmark that each successor has been judged in opposition to.

What made Pochettino distinctive was not simply the win price, however the method of it. Working with out trophy wins, a frustration he and followers shared, he instilled a coherent tactical identification constructed on excessive urgent, youth improvement and aggressive depth. Gamers like Harry Kane, Dele Alli and Son Heung-min flourished beneath his tutelage. A objective distinction of +166 throughout 202 video games is a testomony to his attacking ambition.

Antonio Conte’s arrival in late 2021 offered a special type of excellence, harder-edged, defensively organised and ruthlessly pragmatic. His 62.50% factors return included a top-four end and Champions League qualification in 2021–22. Harry Redknapp, the populist hero who guided Spurs to their first Champions League marketing campaign in 2010, sits fourth total at 57.87% throughout a considerable 144-game pattern.

“Beneath Pochettino, Spurs felt like a membership going someplace. Beneath others, they felt like a membership entering into circles.”

The Worst: Years of Drift and Decline

On the different finish of the spectrum, the numbers are damning. Ossie Ardiles, adored as a participant on the membership, proved catastrophically out of his depth as supervisor. His 1993–94 tenure produced a factors proportion of simply 38.27% from 54 video games, with a detrimental objective distinction and an attacking philosophy so open that it left the defence chronically uncovered. He was sacked after a 3–0 house defeat to Notts County.

Jacques Santini managed simply 11 Premier League video games earlier than his mysterious resignation in October 2004, returning an anaemic 39.39%, although the small pattern makes a good verdict tough. Extra telling is Juande Ramos, appointed on the again of a League Cup triumph and using excessive from European kind, whose league administration produced a determined 39.05%, a determine that contributed to Spurs sitting backside of the Premier League by the point he was dismissed in October 2008.

George Graham’s three years signify maybe probably the most baffling appointment within the membership’s trendy historical past. Employed from rivals Arsenal, the place he had received two titles however was sacked for monetary misconduc, Graham introduced a stifling defensive philosophy solely at odds with the membership’s attacking traditions. His 42.96% factors return from 97 video games was accompanied by tedious soccer that drove followers to distraction, although he did ship the 1999 League Cup.

The Center Floor: Missed Alternatives

A number of managers occupy an fascinating center territory, succesful sufficient to keep away from catastrophe, however unable to achieve the heights the fanbase craved. José Mourinho’s 54.60% return from 58 video games sits beneath the membership common of 51% by only some factors on the floor, but the decline within the second half of his tenure was steep: a fourth-place league end in 2020–21 all however secured earlier than he was dismissed 72 hours earlier than the League Cup last.

Harry Redknapp at 57.87% stands out as the nice “what if”, his 4 years included qualification for the Champions League and constant top-four challenges, however he was controversially missed for the England job and finally dismissed by Daniel Levy regardless of a robust end to 2011–12. Glenn Hoddle’s 42.70% throughout two years (2001–2003) tells the story of a tactically revolutionary supervisor restricted by a skinny squad, whereas Gerry Francis’s three years (1994–1997) at 46.22% have been characterised by warning slightly than ambition.

The Submit-Pochettino Malaise

Since Pochettino’s dismissal in November 2019, Tottenham have employed seven completely different managers within the area of six years, a statistic that speaks to a structural dysfunction past any particular person’s failings. The info bears out the turbulence: Mourinho at 54.60%, Nuno Espírito Santo at 50.00% from simply 10 video games, Conte at 62.50% (the only real vivid spot), Cristian Stellini’s caretaker stint at a disastrous 33.33%, Ange Postecoglou at 45.61% in his two seasons, Thomas Frank at 37.18% within the present marketing campaign, and now Igor Tudor’s arrival with a 0.00% return from one PL outing.

Postecoglou is a very sophisticated case. His total factors return of 45.61% within the league was beneath par, but he delivered the membership’s first trophy in 17 years, the 2025 UEFA Europa League, making his tenure unimaginable to evaluate by statistics alone. Equally, Conte’s 62.50% return seems to be glorious in isolation, however his departure amid a now-infamous press convention tirade and mid-season resignation left the membership in chaos.

Full Statistical Desk — All PL Period Managers

✦ ✦ ✦

Verdict: What the Numbers In the end Inform Us

Soccer statistics alone can not seize the total image, Ange Postecoglou received a European trophy on a threadbare funds, Ossie Ardiles was undermined by a chaotic switch coverage not solely of his making, and Tim Sherwood’s small pattern distorts his rating. However as a broad map of managerial high quality within the Premier League period, the info is revealing.

Pochettino stands alone because the definitive finest: a sustained 63.04% return throughout 5 full seasons, a Champions League last, and a taking part in identification that also resonates. The worst, when it comes to sustained poor efficiency with sufficient assets, is George Graham, introduced in for credibility, he delivered neither outcomes nor leisure throughout three underwhelming years.

The sample that emerges most starkly is the post-2019 managerial carousel. Within the six years since Pochettino, no full-term appointment has matched his benchmark. The membership’s ambitions, a billion-pound stadium, world-class infrastructure, now demand a supervisor able to sustaining 60%-plus factors returns. The info confirms that Spurs have discovered that normal solely as soon as in over three many years. Discovering it once more stays the nice problem.